9. Berkeley Springs, WV: Riley Crossman

Riley Crossman was kind, gentle, and as dramatic as teenagers come. She was a gifted singer and dancer and loved spending her free time with her best friend, Jasmine. 

On May 8, 2019, when her high school called to inform her mom that she hadn't been present that day, the search would lead to a monster in her home. 

Riley's last text messages to her boyfriend Haydn

 .    

DNA Evidence in her room

Camera's that picked up Andy traveling through town the day she's missing